By Toby McIntosh
The World Bank’s Access to Information Appeal Board has ruled that the Bank “acted in good faith and did not violate” the Access to Information Policy despite having taken almost a year to respond to a request.
The decision appears to limit options for requesters if the World Bank delays in responding to requests for documents.
Ten months after filing a request, Eye on Global Transparency (EYE) asked the Board to get involved. “Delay effectively amounts to denial,” EYE said in its letter to the panel, composed of three independent persons.
EYE wrote on Aug. 19, 2026, after receiving no substantive response to a request filed on Sept. 29, 2025, for progress reports on a road-building project in Mozambique.
The Bank delayed transmitting EYE’s Aug. 19 appeal to the Board until Sept. 10, during which time a Bank official tried to talk EYE out of writing to the Board.
A week later, on Sept. 17, the Bank released 14 aide memoires concerning the Mozambique project.
The Board cited a variety for not getting involved, but also praised the Bank.
First, the Board raised a procedural objection, calling EYE’s appeal “premature.” Second, the Board accepted the Bank’s justifications for the delay. And finally, the release of the documents made EYE’s appeal moot, the Board said in its ruling.
The Board’s arguments suggest that other such appeals about delay are unlikely to succeed.
“Premature”
On the procedural front, the Board pointed out that the Bank’s access policy sets no time limit for responding to requests and that the Board can only get involved after decisions are made at the first stage of appeals, to the internal Access to Information Committee (AIC).
EYE’s complaint about delays in the handling of the Mozambique request preceded the Bank’s answer to the request.
The Bank attempts to adhere to a 20 working day time frame for responses, but additional time may be justified “in special circumstances, including, for example, those involving complex or voluminous requests, or requests requiring review by or consultations with internal Bank units, external parties, the AI Committee, or the Board.” (The Bank’s ATI Policy Directive, at Section III.C.1).
As a result, the Board stated, “There is not any definitive time limit for responses to ATI requests….”
Also, the Board also said it could not review EYE’s appeal because its jurisdiction applies only after an appeal has been made about a decision by the Access to Information Committee.
However, the Board cited several instances in which it has previously voiced concerns about delays.
In those decisions, the Board summarized in its latest ruling, it “was concerned that the Bank’s policies and procedures created a potential loophole that the AIAB sought to address (namely, an indefinite delay on an AIC decision rendered a Requester with no recourse for further action).”
Specifically, the Board wrote:
- There is precedent for the AIAB to “properly intervene in a case where there has been both an unreasonable delay and the Bank has not demonstrated its due diligence in locating and reviewing a large number of documents” even when an appeal cannot be admitted (see AIAB Decision #11, Case No. AI6479: Documents concerning amendments to the Tanzanian Statistics Act (Decision dated March 18, 2020), at paragraph 16 ). The AIAB in that decision found that it lacked authority to admit the appeal but expressed concerns with how the Bank handled written communications with the Requester regarding the nature and volume of the responsive records. A further decision in this same case, dated September 2020, responded to an appeal alleging “unreasonable delay” and found that the appeal could not be admitted, despite the concerns of the AIAB (see AIAB Decision #12, Case No. AI6479: Documents concerning amendments to the Tanzanian Statistics Act (Decision dated September 4, 2020), at paragraphs 14-15 ).
The Mozambique case is different, the Board said, because no appeal was filed with the AIC.
Text of decision: Mozambique AIAB Delay Decision 2026 (Both all AIC and AIAB decisions can be found on an Appeals page on the Bank website.)
“Timely and Candid Updates”
Despite its refusal to get involved, the Board complimented the Bank’s handling of the Mozambique request.
The Board noted that in the two cited previous decisions it “had concerns about how the request was handled and about the ‘lack of meaningful, open and frank communication with the Requester.’ “
However, the Board continued, “… in this instant case the Bank kept in continuous contact with the Requester, providing timely and candid updates on the request status, even when there was a lack of progress.”
The delay messages were indeed about monthly, though usually only after EYE asked for a status update. The emails were vaguely encouraging though not particularly informative.
In its appeal to the Board, EYE quoted these from emails:
Dec. 1 – “… we are following up with the relevant staff.”
Feb. 10 – “We’re pursuing a decision.”
March 2 – “… hope to wrap this up soon …”
April 21 – “… we’re now very close to closing this one out.”
May 28 – “… hope we can get back to you soon.”
June 15 – “… this is active but don’t have a resolution yet.”
July 28 – “… not resolved yet.”
The request wasn’t complex, a Bank official admitted.
“You’re right that this has taken a long time, and I understand your frustration — especially given that this isn’t a complex request,” wrote Senior Communications Officer Claudia Gabarain on April 21. But, she continued: “Even with relatively straightforward cases, it can sometimes take longer than it should to work through all the internal steps and get the necessary inputs from colleagues, particularly when they’re in different offices and time zones. That said, I do believe we’re now very close to closing this one out.”
The Board apparently requested information from the Bank about the handling of the Mozambique request and was satisfied.
“Regarding the Requester’s allegation of intentional excessive delay, in reviewing internal communications at the Bank, the AIAB found no evidence of intentional or excessive delay – in fact, quite the opposite.” It continued, “The need for extensive internal coordination with the business unit, including outreach to the Government for feedback on release, created an unavoidable delay between the time that the request was received and the requested information was disclosed.”
The World Bank eventually disclosed 14 reports about the six-year-old road-building project in Mozambique that is nearing completion. (See EYE article Sept. 22, 2026.) The most recent was dated May 29, 2026.
Aide memoires are the most important periodic evaluations that the Bank prepares about the progress of its projects. However, they are not routinely made public and the Bank usually rejects requests for them. In this case, the Mozambique government agreed to their release, a permission the Bank says is necessary.
The Bank typically cites exemptions in its ATI policy to justify not disclosing aide memories, often saying that releasing them would violate the deliberative process exception.
The Board has not always agreed with the Bank’s rationales and has ordered some aide memoires released.
In its handing of another 2025 EYE request, the Bank’s AIC on Sept. 10 said aide memoires for a project in Lesotho were deliberative and not disclosable.
Getting that opinion from the AIC took more time than usual, which EYE raised in the same “delay is denial” appeal to the Board that also included the Mozambique request. The Board did not address the AIC’s handling of the Lesotho appeal.
Delays in Lesotho Appeal
The Bank denied the Sept. 29, 2025 Lesotho request completely on Feb. 10, 2026, citing the deliberative process exemption. EYE filed an appeal with the AIC on April 13, 2026.
As of Aug. 19, when EYE wrote the Board about the Lesotho case, the AIC decision was overdue.
The access policy says the Committee “makes its best efforts to reach a decision on appeals within 45 working days of receiving an appeal….”
The Committee Secretariat sent notices about every two weeks saying that the Committee “needs additional time.”
As of Aug.19, the “processing” had taken about almost 90 days, twice the 45-day goal.
The AIC denied the appeal on Sept. 10, 2026. (AIC Decision on appeal #103 CASE NUMBER AI10145).
EYE on Oct. 13 appealed to the Board about the AIC’s Lesotho decision.
The appeal objects to the Bank’s reasoning and notes that the Committee did not even mention Board decisions concerning the deliberative process exemption. (See EYE article, Oct. 14, 2026.)
The Bank has not responded to EYE’s questions about how it views Board decisions.
A Board ruling on the Lesotho appeal is pending.